So the official result is nearly in, but the NO VOTE has already now officially passed the 50% mark. The Yes to AV camp had given up and gone home some hours ago, and the first gloating has begun in the largely right wing press.
The Spectator was one of the first off the mark and the inane commentary has begun. Narrow mindedness and self preservation of the 2 main parties has won out and many are now saying openly that thankfully that will be the end of constitutional reform for a generation.
It is likely that I will be dead by the time real constitutional reform comes to the fore, which it surely will one day, it is just that in Britain we are always the last to drag our traditions kicking and screaming into the modern world.
The Alternative Vote was never the best system, everyone knew it, but we also knew that it was always the only reform any of the major players could consider stomaching. But they were able to fight off the challenge to their unfair advantages built into our system.
Nick Clegg made a massive gamble in his coalition agreement and sold his soul for AV. In the end, much of the public could not stomach what he gave up for this.
The No campaign acted disgracefully and it will be hard for many to be able to look on some figures within that campaign in the same light. Baroness Warsi playing at extremism was an absolute disgrace. As was the way the Tories stabbed Nick Clegg in the back with the no campaign and the targeting of him personally.
The lies told over funding and people having more than one vote; and it helping extremism will go down in the political pages of history showing just how to run a cynical and negative campaign. If you repeat a lie often enough people believe it.
In the end, the vote for AV gave the chance for those who like FPTP; those that wanted PR; those that could not forgive Nick Clegg; and those wanting to put strain on the coalition, to all campaign for a no vote.
The Conservative Party, BNP and Communists, and the old guard of the Labour Party won out.
If this is the end of our constitutional reform, it is a sad end to the progress of pluralism seen over the past 15 years. With the partial reform of the House of Lords, devolution and mayoral elections, the benefits of local democracy and a more proportional system can be seen, as with the Scottish elections tonight.
A country should never stand still in a false belief that the past is best. We should be looking forward to see how we can improve. A better more accountable and transparent political system will always improve the quality of govenorship even if those clinging onto power do not think so.